“It is impossible for a man to begin to learn that which he thinks that he knows.”
~ Epictetus, Discourses, Book 2, Chapter 17
Every profession inherits traditions.
Some preserve valuable knowledge. Others preserve explanations, assumptions, and habits that deserve another look.
Chiropractic is no exception.
What Is the Appeal to Tradition?
The appeal to tradition is the assumption that an idea or practice must be correct—or better—because it is old, familiar, or “the way it has always been done.”
It can sound like this:
-
“That is how I was taught.”
-
“We have always treated it this way.”
-
“People have believed this for generations.”
-
“If it were wrong, someone would have changed it by now.”
But repetition is not proof.
Age does not establish accuracy.
And familiarity can make an idea feel true without telling us whether it actually is.
Tradition Is Not Automatically Wrong
This fallacy does not mean that every traditional idea should be discarded.
Old ideas can be correct. New ideas can be wrong.
Tradition may tell us where an idea began and why it became accepted. What it cannot do—by itself—is establish whether that idea still deserves a place in patient care.
That requires evidence.
How It Appears in Healthcare
Healthcare changes as our understanding changes.
A treatment may have been taught for decades. A familiar explanation may be repeated by respected clinicians. A procedure may remain common because patients expect it or because clinicians are comfortable providing it.
None of those things necessarily makes it ineffective.
But none of them proves that it works, either.
A healthcare decision should not rest entirely on:
-
How long something has been practiced
-
How confidently it is explained
-
How many clinicians repeat it
-
How familiar it feels
-
Whether it agrees with what we learned years ago
The more useful question is:
“What does the best available evidence show, and am I willing to update my thinking?”
Chiropractic Should Not Be Frozen in Time
An adjustment may be helpful and appropriate.
It is not automatically the entire treatment plan simply because manipulation has traditionally been associated with chiropractic care.
Depending on the patient and the injury, good care may also involve examination, movement assessment, rehabilitation, progressive exercise, education, imaging, collaboration, or referral.
Tradition can inform clinical judgment.
It should not replace it.
Questions Worth Asking
When you hear, “We’ve always done it this way,” try asking:
-
What problem is this intended to solve?
-
What evidence supports it?
-
Does that evidence apply to this particular patient?
-
Are there risks, limitations, or better alternatives?
-
What information would cause us to change our minds?
The willingness to update an idea is not weakness.
It is part of learning.
Takeaway
Tradition can preserve wisdom.
It can also preserve mistakes.
Thinking is a workout too.
The RiKKE Rule
Be curious.
Question assumptions.
Follow evidence.
Stay willing to change your mind.
Source for the opening quotation:
Epictetus, Discourses, Book II, Chapter 17.
Rikke Johansen
Contact Me